NYSE$FIHL

Fidelis Insurance Holdings Ltd · Q3 2025 earnings

Q3 2025 earnings · · After market close · Investor relations

Briefing

Combined ratio hits record 79.0% as Q3 net income reaches $130.5M

Fidelis Insurance Group reported Q3 2025 results for the three months ended September 30, 2025, with gross premiums written of $797.5 million, up 7.5% year over year, and a combined ratio of 79.0%—its best quarterly result as a public company. Net income was $130.5 million ($1.24 diluted EPS) and operating net income was $126.8 million ($1.21 operating EPS). Annualized operating ROAE was 21.4%. Insurance segment gross premiums written rose to $605.8 million while the Reinsurance segment contributed $191.7 million. The company returned $47.3 million to common shareholders via repurchases and dividends in the quarter. Catastrophe and large losses were $57.4 million, down from $91.6 million a year ago, and net favorable prior-year reserve development was $16.0 million.

  • Gross premiums written were $797.5M (+7.5% YoY) with combined ratio improving to 79.0% from 87.4%
  • Q3 net income was $130.5M ($1.24 EPS); operating net income was $126.8M ($1.21 operating EPS)
  • Annualized operating ROAE reached 21.4%; book value per diluted share was $23.29 (+6.9% YTD)
  • Returned $47.3M to shareholders in Q3 through $31.9M of buybacks and $15.4M of dividends
  • Cat and large losses fell to $57.4M from $91.6M; net favorable prior-year development was $16.0M

Headline financials

EPS (adj)

$1.21

Previous: $0.92+31.5%
Gross premiums written

$798M

No prior period
Combined ratio

79.0%

No prior period
Annualized Operating ROAE

21.4%

No prior period
Net Income

$131M

Previous: $101M+29.7%

Revenue & EPS history

Fidelis · Revenue · Quarterly

$611M

Q1 2026
Beat estimate in 3 of 8 quarters(38%)
ActualEstimate

Revenue by segment

Fidelis · $798M total across 2 segments · Q3 2025

  • Insurance gross premiums written
    $606M
  • Reinsurance Gross Premiums Written
    $192M

Historical earnings impact

How earnings announcements have historically affected this stock's price.

Avg. return before/after earnings

Based on 12 quarterly earnings reports · overlaid with Q3 2025

Historical avgQ3 2025

+1.9%

Avg return

Earnings day

+4.4%

Avg return

5 days after

+5.2%

Avg return

30 days after

62%

8 / 13 earnings

Positive

+14.6%

Q4 2023

Best reaction

-6.7%

Q3 2023

Worst reaction

Earnings price reactions
QuarterReport dateReaction (Day 0)+5 days+30 days
Q1 2026-1.4%+16.2%+16.4%
Q4 2026-3.9%-0.6%+6.6%
Q3 2025-2.3%-1.3%-0.6%
Q2 2025-2.0%-0.7%+0.5%
Q1 2025+2.2%+9.8%+12.4%
Q3 2024+6.9%+5.4%+3.8%
Q2 2024+2.0%+6.5%-0.1%
Q1 2023+3.3%+2.7%+0.6%
Q4 2022+3.3%+2.7%+0.6%
Q4 2021+3.3%+2.7%+0.6%
Q4 2023+14.6%+15.2%+32.1%
Q3 2023-6.7%-10.6%-14.0%
Q2 2023+5.1%+9.8%+8.2%
Q3 2022
Q2 2022
Q1 2022

Discussion

Share your read of this quarter. Sign-in carries your eToro identity.

Join the conversation

Sign in with eToro to post your read of this quarter and vote on others'.

Sign in with eToro